Rock Vs. Rock Star

Thomas Luccock, CIA, CPA
Director of Internal Audit
Michigan State University
East Lansing, Mich.

The concept of an internal auditor being a “rock star” is intriguing, particularly in adding an element of excitement to the profession. But, there is a certain edginess to a rock star, with nostalgia for Woodstock, Liverpool, and the Grammys … do I need to say more?

“Rock,” on the other hand, conveys the message of solid, dependable, ethical, consistent to a fault. It seems to me the profession can be exciting without being flamboyant, surefooted without being careless, stable without insensitivity. Internal audit should be looked on as the gold standard for ethical behavior, prudence, and objectivity.

This level of trust is built through years of discussions with management, well-founded findings, and responsible reporting. You can partner with management without compromising your objectivity, but it does not come overnight. As opposed to a rock star who may rise to preeminence in a flash but may not have staying power, a rock is something that is there for the ages … “Rock of Ages, Cleft to Thine.”

Internal audit should strive to be the gold standard for an organization. We are a profession with standards. Our importance in evaluating internal controls and adding value should be recognized, not only in our reporting relationship but in the day-to-day stability we add to our organizations. Also, our broad-based knowledge from reviewing all aspects of an organization gives us a unique ability to know the inner workings of our organizations. Ergo, get out there, prove your worth as a competent adviser and friend to management, identifying areas of improvement. Be willing to work with management to resolve areas of concern and conflict without compromising a level of objectivity and integrity that can only come from a high level of ethics and good faith.

This should be our challenge for the next decade: Are we solid as a rock with staying power or rock stars who are dependent on the vagaries of the times?
 

Posted on Sep 20, 2011 by Tim

Share This Article:    

  1. Sure, Internal Auditors are the "rock" that can accommodate such moderation with management, stepping in at a point where they are needed the most, even if management may not thing so. To build a professional relationship with management by influencing them to become pro-Internal Auditors. Relationships are not built overnight, so it surely will require patience on the part of the auditor. But what is important is for the auditor to continously be in the influencing side, and not the one to be dissolved in the meanders of management; or , as it is to most of the auditors in our country Tanzania, complain about everybody else except themselves. Auditors have to set the standards; gold standard of conducting affairs of any firm. Auditors should LEARN to be proactive. To be the solutions to problems that the firm may face in far beyond foreseeable future.

  1. It seems like this happens more fnteuqrely with less auditors available to complete the assigned reviews. I've had auditors send out audit notification letters, even conduct pre-audit conferences via phone. Then, they never call back or call/email to to sting along the audit. In general, I only sign waivers on audits that are at least progressing beyond the initial documentation request. However, my issues come up after the first few informations requests are fulfilled. Auditors seem to lose steam. To minimize this I have begun to set up regular status meetings. It seems to have worked so far in that auditors generally make progress within a week or two after these calls. Have to keep doing this as they lose steam again, and again, and again....
  1. Cash really is king a founrte 200 corp I was working with discovered' $ 147 m in interest from interco receivables during the tech go go days.This amount appeared once a ZBA process was implemented. The TMS in question could not reconcile the amounts as there was no note of interest in the orgian loans. Embarassing absolutely, whats more is that there are many more such tales waiting to be told.

Leave a Reply